5 interesting facts about marathon florida 2 622d6334

Top Pizza Places in Marathon

May 9, 2024

When you think of the Florida Keys, your mind may immediately jump to fresh seafood, tropical cocktails, and stunning sunsets. But did you know that Marathon, the heart of the Middle Keys, also boasts an impressive pizza scene?

From classic New York-style slices to innovative wood-fired creations, this island town has something to satisfy every pizza lover’s cravings.

Whether you’re a local looking for your new favorite spot or a visitor planning the perfect Florida Keys getaway, this guide to the best pizza places in Marathon is sure to point you in the right direction. Get ready to indulge in gooey, cheesy goodness and discover the hidden gems that make Marathon’s pizza scene truly shine.

1. Coast to Coast Pizza Company

Address: 61 53rd Street, Marathon, FL 3305
Website: Coast to Coast Pizza

This place in Marathon is consistently ranked as one of the top pizza spots. They have a diverse selection of specialty pizzas and the option to create your own. Their reputation is built on using top-notch ingredients and delivering quick, friendly service.

Freshly baked pizza topped with basil leaves in marathon, florida

2. Driftwood Pizza, Pasta, & Subs

Address: 10875 Overseas Hwy #140, Marathon, FL 33050
Website: Driftwood Pizza

One of the premier pizza places in Marathon, Driftwood has a relaxed, beach-y atmosphere. They offer innovative pizza creations like Spaghetti and Meatballs pizza, as well as other Italian dishes, subs, and a full bar.

Plate of delicious chicken wings coated in a flavorful sauce, photographed at a restaurant in marathon, florida

Discover Sparky's Landing: A Must-Visit Pizza Spot in Marathon, FL

Address: 13205 Overseas Hwy Marathon, FL 33050
Website: Sparky’s Landing

This boho-style waterfront restaurant focuses on wood-fired pizzas with creative toppings like Shrimp and Bacon or Double Garlic. It’s also known as one of the best bars in Marathon with live music.

Delicious pizza topped with fresh ingredients, photographed at a restaurant in marathon, florida.

4. Marathon Grill & Ale House

Address: 5800 Overseas Hwy Marathon, FL 33050
Website: Marathon Grill & Ale House

Choose from a variety of toppings to create your own pizza. Additionally, enjoy a range of seafood, steaks, and other American dishes from their menu. They are renowned for their Prime Rib Fridays.

Delicious quesadilla dish served on a plate at a marathon grill & ale house in marathon, florida

When visiting Marathon, Florida, be sure to explore the top pizza establishments that offer a delightful range of pizza styles, toppings, and dining experiences. Whether you crave a classic Margherita, a hearty meat lover’s pie, or a gourmet creation with unique, locally-sourced ingredients, Marathon’s pizzerias cater to every palate. From cozy, family-run joints to trendy eateries with waterfront views, each spot provides a unique ambiance that enhances your dining experience. Enjoy the perfect slice as you unwind after a day of exploring the Florida Keys.

Recommended Homes For You

Mermaid Manor ~ Waterfront Haven w/ Hot Tub & Dock

Azul Paradise – Waterfront – Heated Pool – Dock

Seabreeze Cove, Waterfront Gem, 38 foot Dock, Cabana Club

Emerald Oasis ~ Lux Waterfront Gem ~ Heated Pool ~ Kayaks

Are You Ready to Experience the Pinnacle of Florida’s Home Rentals?

#bookdirect

Book Your Luxury Escape

⁨B.J.⁩ Earl

Stayed at :
Mermaid’s Paradise ~ Pool ~ Dock ~ Games ~ Views!

5/25/2025

This was our first time to Marathon. First, Michel and Kim were very communicative from the start. They gave great beach and restaurant recommendations before we arrived. Check in was very easy and we had very thorough directions on the process. Home was very nice and clean. Pool was refreshing and relaxing. Lots of parking and could have brought a boat and trailer if we wanted. Michel and Kim checked in a couple of times during our stay to ensure things were good and asking if we needed anything. The stay was great and our first time to the Keys was amazing. We will definitely be back to the Keys and would stay at Michel’s place again!

Rick Tmarsch

Stayed at :
Mermaid Manor ~ Waterfront Haven w/ Hot Tub & Dock

Perfect vacation rental. Everything we needed was available. Excellent outdoor area with a 50’ boat dock on a canal. Love the Marathon area being central to all things Florida keys!

Christy Clement

Stayed at :
Luna Light ~ Waterfront ~ Pool ~ Dock ~ Views!

5/23/2025

Absolutely loved our stay in Marathon!! The home was immaculate and honestly the pictures posted did not do it justice!! Well appointed, extremely comfortable furnishings and more than enough room for all guests! Each room having its own bathroom was a huge plus!! The downstairs was full of entertainment for our group with children of all ages! We all enjoyed the pool, outdoor kitchen and easy access to our boat. Looking forward to making this our go-to place for yearly retreats! Host was responsive to all inquiries and cleaning crew was professional and friendly! Highly recommend!

B.J.

Richard Arthur

Thalita Borges

Stayed at :
Villa Paradise ~ Miami Lux Gem ~ Heated Pool ~ Game Room

5/21/2025

We stayed at this lovely home during our trip to Florida for my graduation, and it turned into a wonderful family vacation. The house is exactly like the pictures—beautiful, clean, and very welcoming. It truly felt like a home away from home. Michel was also very responsive when we messaged him. We cooked family meals in the well-equipped kitchen and spent lots of time enjoying the pool together. Honestly, you didn’t need to leave the house unless you wanted to—it had everything we needed to relax and enjoy our time. Thank you for sharing your home with us. We made great memories here!

Mark Scullion

Stayed at :
Luxury Seaside Escape ~ Pool ~ Dock ~ Scenic Views

5/20/2025

Fantastic place in a fantastic location. This is a can't miss stay. If you are looking for a high quality, private place to have sun and fun - look no further.

Rodney Martin

5/19/2025

Michel’s home was absolutely amazing. Perfect location, his pictures do not do the home justice. Everything from the exterior finishings, interior finishings, and the outside decor is perfect for a Florida Keys vacation. The 75 ft doc had ample space, and everything from manatees to tarpon viewing was a plus. The pool is a good size and was convenient when coming off of the boat, and a cool place to hang out at night with the family. There is a fire pit, ping pong table, corn hole to keep everybody busy and happy. The breeze through the outside location made is very easy to just hang out and watch a games on the big screen tv, and the furniture was comfortable. Their is a outside freezer for bait, and ice. The propane grilled was big enough to cook the fresh caught fish, and burgers/hotdogs at the same time. The inside gave everybody their own space when needed with each bedroom having their own private bath. The kitchen has everything a family needs to cook. I rate this 5 +

Thalita

5/18/2025

Mark

5/17/2025

Mylie

Stayed at :
Emerald Oasis ~ Lux Waterfront Gem ~ Heated Pool ~ Kayaks

5/16/2025

All 8 adults had a blast & so nice to come back & relax at such a beautiful home & backyard.

Christy