Where to Go in Marathon, Florida: The Complete Neighborhood Guide for Vacation Renters
Share:
Discover Marathon’s Best Neighborhoods for Your Vacation
Choosing the right neighborhood can make or break your Florida Keys vacation. Each area of Marathon offers a distinct experience, from the upscale amenities of Key Colony Beach to the authentic fishing village charm of Boot Key. As local vacation rental experts with over 30 years of experience, we’ll guide you through Marathon’s best neighborhoods to help you find your perfect waterfront escape.
Key Colony Beach: Luxury Island Living
Key Colony Beach is Marathon’s premier residential community and the crown jewel for vacation renters seeking an upscale experience. This incorporated city within Marathon offers:
- Private beaches – Unlike most of the Keys, Key Colony Beach has its own sandy beach areas
- Golf course access – The Key Colony Beach Golf Course is a 9-hole par 3 course perfect for casual rounds
- Sunset Park – A stunning waterfront park ideal for watching legendary Florida Keys sunsets
- Walking/biking paths – Quiet streets perfect for morning jogs or evening strolls
- Upscale dining – Restaurants like Sparky’s Landing and Key Colony Inn
Best for: Families, couples seeking romance, golfers, and those wanting a quiet, upscale atmosphere.
Stay here: Deep Blue offers 4 bedrooms with a private dock in Key Colony Beach. Seabreeze Cove provides waterfront luxury with stunning canal views.
Coco Plum Beach: Exclusive Gated Community
For those seeking privacy and exclusivity, Coco Plum Beach offers a gated community experience with some of Marathon’s most prestigious waterfront homes. This neighborhood features:
- Gated security – 24-hour access control for peace of mind
- Deep-water docks – Perfect for larger boats and fishing vessels
- Direct ocean access – Quick access to offshore fishing grounds
- Secluded atmosphere – Limited traffic and quiet streets
- Proximity to Sombrero Beach – Marathon’s best public beach is minutes away
Best for: Boating enthusiasts, anglers targeting offshore species, families wanting privacy, and those seeking a more exclusive experience.
Vaca Key: Central Marathon
Vaca Key is the heart of Marathon, home to the historic downtown area and the famous Seven Mile Bridge. This central location offers:
- Walkable downtown – Restaurants, shops, and services within walking distance
- Marathon Marina – Charter fishing, boat rentals, and watersports
- Turtle Hospital – World-famous sea turtle rescue center
- Crane Point Museum – 63 acres of nature trails and Keys history
- Seven Mile Bridge views – Iconic sunsets over the old and new bridges
Best for: First-time visitors, those without cars, families with kids, and anyone wanting easy access to attractions.
Stay here: Azul Paradise puts you in the heart of Marathon with luxury canal-front accommodations and a heated pool.
Duck Key: Private Island Paradise
Connected to Marathon by a causeway, Duck Key feels like its own private island. This exclusive community offers:
- Hawks Cay Resort – Full-service marina, restaurants, and spa
- Dolphin Connection – Swim with dolphins experiences
- Saltwater lagoon – Calm waters perfect for paddleboarding
- Tennis and pickleball – Multiple courts for guests
- Island atmosphere – True escape from the mainland feel
Best for: Resort amenity seekers, families with children, couples on romantic getaways, and those wanting an all-inclusive feel.
Grassy Key: Natural Beauty and Marine Life
Just north of Marathon proper, Grassy Key offers a more natural, less developed experience with world-famous attractions:
- Dolphin Research Center – Swim with dolphins and learn about marine mammals
- Florida Keys Aquarium Encounters – Interactive marine experiences
- Curry Hammock State Park – Kayaking, camping, and nature trails
- Smaller crowds – More peaceful than central Marathon
- Wildlife viewing – Manatees, dolphins, and sea birds abound
Best for: Nature lovers, families with animal-loving kids, kayakers, and those seeking tranquility.
Boot Key: Authentic Keys Character
Boot Key offers an authentic glimpse into old Florida Keys culture. This working waterfront area features:
- Boot Key Harbor – One of the Keys’ largest anchorages with character boats
- Local watering holes – Genuine Keys bars and restaurants
- Affordable options – More budget-friendly than Key Colony Beach
- Fishing culture – Commercial fishing boats and fresh catch available
- Dinghy docks – Easy access to the water
Best for: Budget-conscious travelers, those seeking authentic Keys culture, fishing enthusiasts, and adventurous spirits.
Choosing Your Perfect Marathon Neighborhood
Consider these factors when selecting your vacation base:
| Priority | Best Neighborhood |
|---|---|
| Luxury amenities | Key Colony Beach or Coco Plum |
| Central location | Vaca Key |
| Resort experience | Duck Key |
| Nature/wildlife | Grassy Key |
| Budget-friendly | Boot Key |
| Deep-water boating | Coco Plum Beach |
| Family activities | Vaca Key or Grassy Key |
Ready to Experience Marathon’s Best Neighborhoods?
Explore our curated collection of luxury vacation rentals across Marathon’s finest neighborhoods:
- Deep Blue – 4BR waterfront estate in Key Colony Beach with private dock
- Azul Paradise – Luxury canal-front home with heated pool
- Ocean Muse – Stunning ocean views with modern amenities
- Vista del Mar – Family-friendly retreat with pool and dock
- Seabreeze Cove – Key Colony Beach waterfront escape
